Foreign Direct Investment International Arbitration Moot


Foreign Direct Investment International Arbitration Moot

Matches Results Group Phase 2022 *

Match winner underlined

Time Room Claimant Respondent
Thu 9:003Currim (6, 602.8500)Kreva (6, 600.1500)
Thu 9:004Brower (6, 527.8450)Erskine (6, 610.5750)
Thu 9:005Bucher (6, 569.7500)Virally (6, 626.1500)
Thu 9:006Rezek (6, 590.7000)Carneiro (6, 590.4000)
Thu 9:007Simma (6, 646.1250)Ladreit (6, 620.6250)
Thu 9:008Dillard (6, 589.3750)Palmer (6, 592.6750)
Thu 9:0011Fischer (6, 614.4500)Castilla (6, 555.6500)
Thu 9:001Fabela (6, 592.8750)Morelli (6, 645.1750)
Thu 9:002Salam (6, 624.5500)Tanaka (6, 534.4750)
Thu 11:307Erskine (6, 590.3750)Tarazi (6, 571.0000)
Thu 11:301Carneiro (6, 553.3750)Rau (6, 518.4000)
Thu 11:302Palmer (6, 590.1250)Boni (6, 624.3175)
Thu 11:303Ladreit (6, 626.1000)Dillard (6, 570.0750)
Thu 11:304Camara (6, 570.9250)Owada (6, 579.2750)
Thu 11:3011Decara (6, 580.6500)Petren (6, 550.7750)
Thu 11:3012Mensah (6, 586.5750)Keith (6, 555.6500)
Thu 11:308Ecer (6, 564.9750)Spender (6, 627.1500)
Thu 11:305Salam (6, 570.5500)Morelli (6, 581.1750)
Thu 11:306Mosler (6, 571.8000)Zourek (6, 570.1250)
Thu 14:0011Virally (6, 613.6250)Rezek (6, 646.9250)
Thu 14:006Rau (6, 611.9750)Bucher (6, 660.4000)
Thu 14:008Salmon (6, 540.1750)Fischer (6, 613.7750)
Thu 14:0012Bauer (6, 623.6150)Camara (6, 584.3250)
Thu 14:002Cordova (6, 444.0750)Zoricic (6, 615.3750)
Thu 14:0014Gray (6, 604.2250)Parra (6, 575.6000)
Thu 14:001Tanaka (6, 529.6500)Mosler (6, 570.1250)
Thu 14:0013Zourek (6, 599.5250)Fabela (6, 653.7750)
Thu 14:005Kreva (6, 533.2500)Brower (6, 538.4550)
Thu 14:004Tarazi (6, 568.5500)Currim (6, 557.4000)
Fri 9:001Holguin (6, 601.9750)Orrego (6, 655.5500)
Fri 9:002Zoricic (6, 593.2750)Gray (6, 582.6750)
Fri 9:003Koroma (6, 543.8750)Owada (6, 612.2750)
Fri 9:004Cross (6, 553.2500)Bauer (6, 664.2950)
Fri 9:0012Paz (6, 535.0500)Decara (6, 631.8250)
Fri 9:005Fabela (6, 640.8750)Salam (6, 605.4750)
Fri 9:006Morelli (6, 582.0250)Tanaka (5, 469.4750)
Fri 9:007Erskine (6, 617.3750)Kreva (6, 634.1500)
Fri 9:008Brower (6, 579.8450)Currim (6, 621.4000)
Fri 11:3012Orrego (6, 629.0750)Cordova (6, 543.1000)
Fri 11:3013Bauer (6, 646.6150)Koroma (6, 617.6000)
Fri 11:3014Cross (6, 549.2500)Camara (6, 613.3250)
Fri 11:301Decara (6, 608.6500)Mensah (6, 621.2250)
Fri 11:302Petren (6, 606.9250)Paz (6, 640.8250)
Fri 11:306Mosler (6, 492.8000)Fabela (6, 547.7750)
Fri 11:303Palmer (6, 557.1250)Ladreit (6, 601.6250)
Fri 11:304Dillard (6, 603.3750)Simma (6, 635.8500)
Fri 11:307Spender (6, 557.5500)Castilla (6, 547.6500)
Fri 11:308Ecer (6, 551.9750)Fischer (6, 642.7750)
Fri 11:3011Parra (6, 582.9250)Holguin (6, 580.3750)
Fri 14:001Fischer (6, 638.4500)Spender (6, 620.1500)
Fri 14:002Salmon (6, 535.1750)Ecer (6, 454.2750)
Fri 14:0013Gray (6, 582.2250)Holguin (6, 567.3750)
Fri 14:003Zoricic (6, 623.2750)Parra (6, 604.6000)
Fri 14:004Petren (6, 644.9250)Keith (6, 609.6500)
Fri 14:005Currim (6, 585.8500)Erskine (6, 583.5750)
Fri 14:006Tarazi (6, 579.5500)Brower (6, 584.4550)
Fri 14:007Bucher (6, 610.7500)Carneiro (6, 611.4000)
Fri 14:008Rau (6, 533.9750)Rezek (6, 584.9250)
Fri 14:0011Simma (6, 651.1250)Palmer (6, 657.6750)
Fri 14:0012Boni (6, 599.4625)Dillard (6, 582.0750)
Fri 16:303Koroma (6, 559.8750)Cross (6, 533.8250)
Sat 9:006Ladreit (6, 572.1000)Boni (6, 583.3175)
Sat 9:007Castilla (6, 571.2250)Salmon (6, 586.4250)
Sat 9:008Cordova (6, 516.0750)Gray (6, 631.6750)
Sat 9:0011Orrego (6, 597.0750)Zoricic (6, 570.3750)
Sat 9:001Camara (6, 591.9250)Koroma (6, 585.6000)
Sat 9:0013Paz (6, 535.0500)Mensah (6, 600.2250)
Sat 9:0014Keith (6, 595.7000)Decara (6, 647.8250)
Sat 9:002Tanaka (6, 578.6500)Zourek (6, 591.1250)
Sat 9:0012Owada (6, 646.3000)Bauer (6, 648.2950)
Sat 9:003Morelli (6, 625.0250)Mosler (6, 560.1250)
Sat 9:004Kreva (6, 613.2500)Tarazi (6, 611.0000)
Sat 9:005Virally (6, 625.6250)Rau (6, 575.4000)
Sat 11:3011Keith (6, 527.7000)Paz (6, 588.8250)
Sat 11:301Carneiro (6, 585.3750)Virally (6, 617.1500)
Sat 11:302Rezek (6, 648.7000)Bucher (6, 679.4000)
Sat 11:303Spender (6, 599.5500)Salmon (6, 595.4250)
Sat 11:304Castilla (6, 623.2250)Ecer (6, 607.2750)
Sat 11:305Parra (6, 557.9250)Orrego (6, 629.5500)
Sat 11:306Holguin (6, 563.9750)Cordova (6, 480.1000)
Sat 11:308Owada (6, 598.3000)Cross (6, 549.8250)
Sat 11:307Boni (6, 550.4625)Simma (6, 624.8500)
Sat 11:3013Zourek (6, 556.5250)Salam (6, 594.4750)
Sat 11:3012Mensah (6, 532.5750)Petren (6, 533.7750)

Victors by Group

Before the oral hearings, teams are seeded into groups based on their memorial results. In each of the groups, the top 1 team advances. In addition, the two best ranked second placed teams advance.

GroupTeamWinsSBVotesz-points
6Morelli47101801.00
6Fabela3591750.00
6Salam2171781.00
6Mosler2141607.00
6Zourek151720.00
7Currim3651685.00
7Erskine23111782.00
7Kreva2361750.00
7Brower2321636.00
7Tarazi1361743.00
8Rezek35101878.00
8Virally3491853.00
8Bucher2341840.00
8Carneiro2261723.00
9Simma3581884.00
9Boni3491768.00
9Palmer2331772.00
9Ladreit2271771.00
10Fischer46111841.00
10Spender3381793.00
10Salmon2181678.00
10Castilla131656.00
11Orrego45111870.00
11Zoricic3491817.00
11Gray32101809.00
11Parra1111656.00
11Holguin151709.00
12Bauer46121983.00
12Owada3381789.00
12Camara2171702.00
12Koroma121702.00
13Mensah35101735.00
13Decara3471812.00
13Petren2371777.00
13Paz2261700.00

Within each group, teams are ranked according to:
Wins are matches won on the basis of the total raw scores of the arbitrators added to each team’s weighted (25%) claimant or respondent memorial score. This criterion allows weight to be given to a team‘s memorials and counter-acts teams that may rely on the work other teams may have put into memorials, which then become available to opposing teams (caveat: total raw scores can be distorted by individual high- or low scoring arbitrators).

SB is the total number of wins of those teams against which a team has won. This criterion takes account of the strength of the opposition that a team has faced.Neustadtl Sonneborn-Berger

Votes is the total number of arbitrators who in each match have given a team’s two advocates a higher aggregate point total. This criterion flattens out the phenomenon of high- or low scorers and takes account that matches may be won 3:0, 2:1 or even rarely 1:2 ( if the ”1” is an unusually high-scorer and/or the winning team had a significantly higher memorial score).

z-Points are the total normalised points a team has received in its four preliminary round matches. It is rare that over four matches two teams would have exactly the same number of total points, so this can provide a tie-break where other methods fail. Normalising using the “z-score” formula (using standard deviations) seeks to mitigate inequities caused by high- or low scorers (caveat: the quality of statistical methods depends on many variables).

Teams that won no matches are not shown above.